Global Broker Regulation Inquiry App
About WikiFX
Broker Search
English

简体中文

繁體中文

English

Pусский

日本語

ภาษาไทย

Tiếng Việt

Bahasa Indonesia

Español

हिन्दी

Filippiiniläinen

Français

Deutsch

Português

Türkçe

한국어

العربية

اردو

Download

IG 、XTB 交易商比较(前端未翻译)

Do you want to know which is the better broker between IG and XTB ?

在下表中,您可以并排比较 IG 、 XTB 的功能,以确定最适合您的交易需求。(前端未翻译)

  • Rating
  • Basic Information
  • Trading Env.
  • Account Info
  • Related News
  • Relevant Exposures
  • Rating
  • Basic Information
  • Trading Env.
  • Account Info
  • Related News
  • Relevant Exposures
 2 / 3  forex brokers comparison in total
Rating
Score
Regulatory Status
WikiFX Guarantee
WikiFX Survey
Risk Evaluation
Exposure
Basic Information
Est. Date
Regulatory License
MT4
MT5
Crypto
Deposit/Withdrawal Methods
Trading Env.
Trading Environment Rating
Execution Speed
Trading Speed Rating
Average Execution Speed
Minimum Execution Latency
Minimum Open Latency
Minimum Close Latency
Maximum Execution Latency
Maximum Open Latency
Maximum Close Latency
Slippage
Slippage Rating
Average Slippage
Max Slippage
Maximum Positive Slippage
Maximum Negative Slippage
Trading Cost
Trading Cost Rating
  • Average Trading Cost
  • (EURUSD)
  • Average Trading Cost
  • (XAUUSD)
Swap
Swap Rating
  • Average Trading Cost
  • (EURUSD)
  • Average Trading Cost
  • (XAUUSD)
Disconnection Instances
Disconnection Rating
Avg. Disconnection Frequency (/day)
Avg. Reconnection Time
Account Info
Accounts
Account Name
Trading Instruments
Minimum Deposit
Maximum Leverage
Typical Spread
Stop-Out Level
Spread Types
Minimum Trade Size
Crypto
Lock Position
Scalping
EA Trading
IG
8.26
Regulated
Under guarantee
20+ years
ASIC,ASIC,FCA,FSA,FCA,FMA,BaFin,FMA,DFSA,FSCA,MAS,NFA
--
B
C
516
265
265
282
1125
1125
953
AA
--
--
--
--
C
--
34.3 USD/Lot
A

Long: -7.31

Short: 2.63

Long: -38.25

Short: 12.56

C
0.5
4
Standard account,DMA account
Foreign exchange, precious metals, CFD
no minimum deposit requirement
1:200
EURUSD 0.6 Gold 0.3
0.00
floating
0.1,0.01(MT4)
--
XTB
6.94
Regulated
Under guarantee
15-20 years
CYSEC,FCA,ICDX,BAPPEBTI
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--

IG 、 XTB BrokerRelated News

IG 、 XTB BrokerRelevant Exposures

Which broker is more reliable?

To evaluate a broker's reliability and trustworthiness, consider the following four factors:

1.Forex broker introduction。

2.Do ig and xtb have lower transaction costs?

3.Which broker is safer?

4.Which broker offers the best trading platform?

Based on these four factors, we can compare which is reliable. We have broken down the reasons as follows:

Forex broker introduction

ig
Quick IG Review Summary
Founded in1974
Registered inUnited Kingdom
RegulationASIC, FCA, FSA, FMA, MAS, DFSA
Market instruments17,000+, forex, indices, shares, commodities, cryptocurrencies
Demo Account($20,000 virtual funds)
Min Deposit$0
LeverageUp to 1:400
EUR/USD SpreadFrom 0.6 pips
Trading platformL2 dealer, ProRealTime, MT4, TradingView
Copy Trading
Payment MethodCredit/debit cards, bank transfer
Customer Service24 hours a day, except 6 am - 4pm on Saturday (UTC+8) - live chat
Regional RestrictionsUSA

General Information

IG is a UK-registered company and regulated by multiple international financial bodies, including the ASIC, FCA, FSA, FMA, MAS, and DFSA. It offers access to a 17,000+ markets, including forex, indices, shares, commodities, and cryptocurrencies. The company provides multiple trading platforms, including L2 dealer, ProRealTime, MT4, and TradingView.

IG's home page

What Type of Broker Is IG?

IG is a Market Making (MM) broker, which means that it acts as a counterparty to its clients in trading operations. That is, instead of connecting directly to the market, IG acts as an intermediary and takes the opposite position to its clients. As such, it can offer faster order execution speed, tighter spreads and greater flexibility in terms of offering leverage.

However, this also means that IG has a certain conflict of interest with their clients, as their profits come from the difference between the bid and ask price of assets, which could lead to them making decisions that are not necessarily in the best interest of their clients. It is important for traders to be aware of this dynamic when trading with IG or any other MM broker.

Pros and Cons of IG

Pros:

  • Wide variety of markets and instrument options
  • Intuitive and customizable trading platforms
  • Access to advanced technical analysis and charting tools
  • Multilingual, multi-channel customer service
  • Demo account with virtual financing of $20,000
  • No minimum deposit requirement for real accounts
  • Leverage up to 1:400

Cons:

  • Fees and costs may not be clearly specified
  • Withdrawal of funds is not clearly specified
  • The minimum transaction amount is high for some markets
  • Credit card deposit fees are high compared to other brokers

Is IG Legit?

Yes. IG is currently regulated by multiple regulatory authorities, including ASIC (Australia), FCA (UK), FSA (Japan), FMA (New Zealand), MAS (Singapore), and DFSA (UAE).

Regulated CountryRegulatorRegulated EntityLicense TypeLicense No.
Australia
Australia Securities & Investment Commission (ASIC)IG AUSTRALIA PTY LTDMarket Making (MM)515106
UK
Financial Conduct Authority (FCA)IG MARKETS LIMITEDMarket Making (MM)195355
Japan
Financial Services Agency (FSA)IG証券株式会社Retail Forex License関東財務局長(金商)第255号
New Zealand
Financial Markets Authority (FMA)IG AUSTRALIA PTY LTDStraight Through Processing (STP)684191
Singapore
Monetary Authority of Singapore (MAS)IG ASIA PTE LTDRetail Forex LicenseUnreleased
United Arab Emirates
Dubai Financial Services Authority (DFSA)United Arab EmiratesRetail Forex LicenseF001780
Regulated by ASIC

Regulated by FCA

Regulated by FSA
Regulated by FMA

Regulated by MAS

Regulated by DFSA

Market Instruments

IG offers access to 17,000+ markets, covering forex, indices, shares, commodities, and cryptocurrencies.

Tradable Instruments Supported
Forex
Shares
Indices
Commodities
Thematic and basket
Options
Futures
Spot
Cryptocurrencies
Bonds
ETFs
Mutual Funds
Market Instruments

Account Type

IG offers a single live account withno minimum deposit required. Aside from live accounts, demo accounts are also available.

IG's demo account is a very useful tool for beginner traders, as it allows them to trade in a safe and risk-free environment. With IG's virtual funding of $20,000, traders can practice and hone their trading skills without risking their capital. In addition, the IG demo account provides access to the trading platform and all the instruments and tools available in the live account, allowing traders to familiarize themselves with the platform and test different trading strategies.

Leverage

As for the maximum leverage dimension at IG, the company offers a maximum leverage of up to 1:400. This means that traders can open positions that are 400 times larger than their available capital. Leverage can be a powerful tool for experienced traders, as it allows them to earn higher profits with limited capital. However, it can also significantly increase the risk of loss and it is important that traders fully understand the risks and limitations of leverage before using it.

Spread and Commission

In terms of costs, IG offers competitive, with EUR/USD spread starting from 0.6 pips. However, there is not much information available on commissions, which may create uncertainty for some traders. In addition, it is important to note that costs may be higher in less liquid markets or with lower trading volume.

Trading Platform

IG offers various trading platforms to meet the needs of different types of traders.

The web-based platform is intuitive and easy to use, although it may be less customizable than other platforms.

They also offer MetaTrader 4, a popular and well-known platform in the forex industry.

For experienced traders, L2 Dealer offers a wide range of advanced tools and functionalities. However, this platform can be more complicated for beginner traders.

Mobile apps are available for iOS and Android, allowing traders to trade on the go.

Trading Platform

Deposit and Withdrawal

The minimum deposit for card payment is $50, and no minimum deposit required for Bank Transfer.

Deposit options including immediate credit/debit card transactions upon card registration, with up to five cards permissible per account.

For Hong Kong clients, cost-free FPS transfers in HKD are available and usually clear within one business day.

Bank transfers are also supported. Always include your account ID as a reference to ensure prompt and accurate allocation of funds.

However, fees of 1% are charged on Visa deposits and 0.5% on Mastercard deposits.

Unfortunately, there is no detailed information on withdrawal of funds, which may be a drawback for some customers.

deposit options

IG Markets enables convenient funding through its mobile app, accessible under the 'add funds' section for both iPhone and Android users. Additionally, transfers can be made via Wise (formerly TransferWise), though users should check for any associated fees as IG Markets is not affiliated with Wise. For Wise transfers, proof of transaction and account details may be required.

mobile app
deposit and withdrawal

Conclusion

In conclusion, IG is a well-established and regulated trading platform that offers a wide variety of financial instruments, an intuitive web platform and access to MetaTrader 4 and L2 Dealer. Although its demo account offers generous virtual funding, information on live accounts is limited. Multilingual customer service is available through multiple channels. However, there is very limited information on deposit and withdrawal.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

What is the minimum deposit required to open an account with IG?

No minimum deposit requirement.

What deposit methods are accepted on IG?

IG accepts deposits through credit/debit cards and bank transfers.

What is the maximum leverage offered by IG?

1:400.

What trading platforms does IG offer?

IG offers L2 dealer, ProRealTime, MT4, and TradingView.

Risk Warning

Trading online carries inherent risks, including the potential loss of invested capital. It may not be suitable for all traders or investors. It's essential to understand and acknowledge these risks before engaging in online trading.

xtb
Quick XTB Review Summary
Founded in 1995
Registered inUK
Regulated byCySEC, FCA
Trading Instruments6,898, stocks, ETFs, forex, indices, commodities
Demo Account
Min Deposit£0
LeverageUp to 1:500
EUR/USD SpreadFloating around 1.0 pips
Trading PlatformMobile, Desktop, Tablet
Payment MethodxStation5 (Mobile, Desktop, Tablet)
Deposit Fee
Withdrawal FeeFree for withdrawal above 50 USD/EUR/GBP
5 USD/EUR/GBP for withdrawal below 50 USD/EUR/GBP
Inactivity FeeA monthly fee of 10 GBP will be charged if no purchase or sale transaction within 365 days
Customer Support24/5 live chat
Tel: +44 2036953086
Email: uksales@xtb.com

XTB Information

XTB is a UK registered online forex and CFD broker that is regulated by the FCA and CYSEC. The company offers trading in 6,898 financial instruments including stocks, ETFs, forex, indices, and commodities with leverage up to 1:500, spread from 0.5 pips and zero commissions for CFD trading via Mobile, Desktop, and Tablet platforms.

XTBs homepage

Pros and Cons of XTB

Pros:

  • Regulated by CySEC and FCA
  • Commission-free trading
  • No minimum deposit requirement
  • Rich educational resources including educational articles, market analysis, aneBooks

Cons:

  • Only offers a standard account type
  • Withdrawal below 50 USD/EUR/GBP will be charged a fee of 5 USD/EUR/GBP
  • A monthly fee of 10 GBP will be charged if no purchase or sale transaction within 365 days
  • Customer support is not available 24/7

Is XTB Legit?

Yes. XTB is currently regulated by Cyprus Securities and Exchange Commission (CySEC) and Financial Conduct Authority (FCA).

Regulated CountryRegulatorRegulated EntityLicense TypeLicense No.
Cyprus
CySECXTB LtdMarket Making (MM)169/12
UK
FCAXTB LimitedStraight Through Processing (STP)522157
Regulated by CySEC
Regulated by FCA

Market Instruments

XTB offer 6,898 tradable instruments, including stocks, ETFs, forex, indices, and commodities. This presents a great opportunity for traders to diversify their portfolio and access multiple markets all within one platform.

Asset ClassSupported
CFDs
Stocks
ETFs
Forex
Indices
Commodities
Cryprocurrencies
Bonds
Options

Account Type

XTB only offers a single standard account type, and no minimum deposit requirement.

There are no fees for account opening and maintenance, while 0.5% for currency conversion.

Leverage

XTB offers a maximum leverage of up to 1:500. However, traders need to be aware that high leverage also carries a higher risk of substantial losses, and should only be used by experienced traders who have a good understanding of risk management strategies.

Spreads and Commissions

XTB offers spread from 0.5 pips. Specifically, spread on the EUR/USD pair is floating around 1.0 pips.

As for commissions, there is no commission for trading CFDs, while there may be a commission charged for stocks and ETFs investing. You can find detailed info in the table below:

Commission for trading CFDs
Stocks and ETFs investing commissionFor monthly turnover equivalent up to 100, 000 EUR
After that0.2%, min 10 GBP

Trading Platform

XTB only offers its proprietary platform, available on Mobile, Desktop, and Tablet devices. It does not support any third-party trading platforms, such as the industry-leading MT4 and MT5, which could be a disadvantage for some traders.

Trading PlatformSupported Available Devices Suitable for
Proprietary platformMobile, Desktop, Tablet/
MT4/Beginners
MT5/Experienced traders

Deposit and Withdrawal

XTB accepts payments via MasterCard, Maestro, Visa, Bank transfer.

The accepted currencies are USD, EUR, and GBP.

It does not charge any fees for deposits and process them quickly.

Withdrawal above 50 USD/EUR/GBP is free of charge, while withdrawal below 50 USD/EUR/GBP will be charged a fee of 5 USD/EUR/GBP.

As for the withdrawal processing time, withdrawal before 1 PM can be processed on the same business day, while withdrawal after 1 PM will be processed on the next business day.

Deposits 1
Deposits 2
Withdrawals

Conclusion

Overall, XTB is a well-regulated and reputable forex broker with many years of experience in the industry. The company offers a wide range of tradable assets, competitive spreads, and user-friendly trading platforms with advanced features. The educational resources provided by XTB are also a valuable asset for both novice and experienced traders.

However, the limited account options and high withdrawal fees for small amounts may be a disadvantage for some traders.

Overall, XTB is a solid choice for traders looking for a regulated and reliable forex broker.

Do ig and xtb have lower transaction costs?

To compare transaction costs across different brokers, our experts analyze the transaction-specific fees (such as spreads) and non-trading fees (such as inactivity fees and payment costs).

To get a comprehensive understanding of how cheap or expensive ig and xtb are, we first considered common fees for standard accounts. On ig, the average spread for the EUR/USD currency pair is EURUSD 0.6 Gold 0.3 pips, while on xtb the spread is --.

Which broker between ig, xtb is safer?

To determine the safety of our top brokers, our experts will consider many factors. This includes which licenses the broker holds and the credibility of these licenses. We also consider the history of brokers, because long-term brokers are usually more reliable and trustworthy than new brokers.

ig is regulated by ASIC,ASIC,FCA,FSA,FCA,FMA,BaFin,FMA,DFSA,FSCA,MAS,NFA. xtb is regulated by CYSEC,FCA,ICDX,BAPPEBTI.

Which broker between ig, xtb provides better trading platform?

When our experts review brokers, they will open their own accounts and trade through the broker's trading platform. This enables them to comprehensively evaluate the quality, ease of use, and function of the platform.

ig provides the Standard account,DMA account platform with products like Foreign exchange, precious metals, CFD; xtb offers the -- platform featuring assets including --.

Select Country/Region
United States
※ WikiFX compiles data from publicly available sources and user contributions. While we endeavor to maintain its accuracy, we do not warrant the information's completeness, accuracy, or timeliness, as it may become outdated. Investors are strongly advised to verify critical details with official sources before making any decisions.
You are visiting the WikiFX website. WikiFX Internet and its mobile products are an enterprise information searching tool for global users. When using WikiFX products, users should consciously abide by the relevant laws and regulations of the country and region where they are located.
consumer hotline:006531290538
Official Email:support@wikifx.com;
Mobile Phone Number:234 706 777 7762;61 449895363
Telegram:+60 103342306
Whatsapp:+852-6613 1970;
License or other information error corrections, please send the information to:qa@wikifx.com
Cooperation:business@wikifx.com