简体中文
繁體中文
English
Pусский
日本語
ภาษาไทย
Tiếng Việt
Bahasa Indonesia
Español
हिन्दी
Filippiiniläinen
Français
Deutsch
Português
Türkçe
한국어
العربية
اردو
CMC MARKETS 、eXcentral 交易商比较(前端未翻译)
Do you want to know which is the better broker between CMC MARKETS and eXcentral ?
在下表中,您可以并排比较 CMC MARKETS 、 eXcentral 的功能,以确定最适合您的交易需求。(前端未翻译)
- Rating
- Basic Information
- Trading Env.
- Account Info
- Related News
- Relevant Exposures
- Rating
- Basic Information
- Trading Env.
- Account Info
- Related News
- Relevant Exposures
- Average Trading Cost
- (EURUSD)
- Average Trading Cost
- (XAUUSD)
- Average Trading Cost
- (EURUSD)
- Average Trading Cost
- (XAUUSD)
EURUSD: -0.3
XAUUSD: --
Long: -0.95
Short: 0.23
Long: -0.9
Short: 0.5
Which broker is more reliable?
To evaluate a broker's reliability and trustworthiness, consider the following four factors:
1.Forex broker introduction。
2.Do cmc-markets and excentral have lower transaction costs?
3.Which broker is safer?
4.Which broker offers the best trading platform?
Based on these four factors, we can compare which is reliable. We have broken down the reasons as follows:
Forex broker introduction
cmc-markets
| CMC Markets Review Summary | |
| Founded | 1989 |
| Registered Country | Australia |
| Regulation | FCA, FMA, CIRO, MAS |
| Trading Instruments | 10,000+, forex, indices, commodities, shares, ETFs, treasuries, shares baskets |
| Demo Account | ✅ |
| Account Type | Standard, FX Active |
| Min Deposit | $0 |
| Leverage | Up to 1:200 (Retail) |
| EUR/USD Spread | Average 0.6 pips |
| Trading Platform | MT4/5, CMC NextGen |
| Payment Methods | Credit/debit card, bank transfer, PayID, PayPal |
| Customer Support | 24 hours, Monday - Saturday morning |
| Live chat, contact form | |
| Tel: 1300 303 888, +61 2 8221 2100 (calling from overseas) | |
CMC Markets Information
CMC Markets is an established brokerage firm registered in Australia and regulated by FCA, FMA, MAS, and CIRO. With over 20 years of experience, they offer 12,000+ trading instruments including forex, indices, commodities, shares, and cryptocurrencies. Traders can access their services through the popular MT4/5 platforms as well as CMC NextGen Platform. CMC Markets provides a flexible account structure with no minimum initial deposit requirement and offers free demo accounts for practice trading. They have a strong customer support system, and provide various educational resources to assist traders in their financial journey.

Pros and Cons of CMC Markets
| Pros | Cons |
|
|
| |
| |
| |
|
✅Where CMC Markets Shines:
Operate under a strong regulatory frame: CMC Markets has strong regulatory endorsement. CMC Markets are regulated by top-tier financial authorities, including FMA, FCA, CIRO, and MAS. A strict regulatory system can protect the security of users' assets.
Low spreads and low trading commissions (except stock CFDs): CMC Markets has the lowest fee structure in the industry. Traders trading on this platform can get a better trading experience, but its stock CFD trading fees are higher.
Provide a wide range of trading varieties: Trade CFDs on more than 12,000 instruments across global markets with confidence, including Forex, Indices, Commodities, Cryptocurrencies and more.
Wide range of educational resources: CMC Markets provides investors with a knowledge hub for news & analysis, learn CFD trading and platform guides. Investors can choose learning resources that suit them according to their characteristics and improve their trading capabilities.
No minimum deposit: CMC Markets has no minimum deposit, which is a great advantage for many investors with small amounts of capital.
❌Where CMC Markets Falls Short:
High stock CFD trading fees: Although CMC Markets low trading fees are an advantage, its stock CFD trading fees are very high, and stock CFD investors need to choose other cheaper traders for trading.
Is CMC Markets Legit?
CMC Markets is a globally recognized trading platform, rigorously regulated by several top-tier financial authorities including the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) in the United Kingdom, the Financial Markets Authority (FMA) in New Zealand, the Canadian Investor Protection Fund (CIRO) in Canada, and the Monetary Authority of Singapore (MAS).
These regulations ensure that CMC Markets adheres to strict standards of market making and retail forex trading, offering a secure and transparent trading environment across multiple jurisdictions. This regulatory framework supports CMC Markets' commitment to providing safe and reliable trading services to its clients worldwide.
| Logo | ![]() | ![]() | ![]() | ![]() |
| Regulatory Agency | Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) | Financial Markets Authority (FMA) | Canadian Investment Regulatory Organization (CIRO) | Monetary Authority of Singapore (MAS) |
| Current Status | Regulated | Regulated | Regulated | Regulated |
| Regulated Country | United Kingdom | New Zealand | Canada | Singapore |
| Regulated Entity | CMC Markets UK plc | CMC MARKETS NZ LIMITED | CMC Markets Canada Inc. | CMC MARKETS SINGAPORE PTE LTD |
| License Type | Market Making (MM) | Market Making (MM) | Market Making (MM) | Retail Forex License |
| License No. | 173730 | 41187 | Unreleased | Unreleased |




Market Instruments
CMC Markets provides a diverse range of trading instruments to cater to the needs of different traders. With CFD trading, users have the flexibility to go long or short on a variety of assets including forex, indices, commodities, cryptocurrencies and shares. This allows traders to profit from both rising and falling markets, maximizing their trading opportunities.
In addition, CMC Markets offers share investing in International Shares, Domestic Shares, ETFs, Options, and Crypto. This allows for a comprehensive portfolio diversification and investment in different sectors and industries.
| Products | Offered |
| Forex | ✔ |
| Indices | ✔ |
| Commodities | ✔ |
| Cryptocurrencies | ✔ |
| Shares | ✔ |
| CFDs | ✔ |
| ETFs | ✔ |
| Options | ✔ |
| Bonds | ❌ |

Trading Accounts
CMC Markets provides two account types, namely Standard account and FX Active account. No matter which type of account a user chooses, the products available to the user are very rich. The following introduces the specific contents of the two accounts.
| Account Type | Standard | FX Active |
| Best for | All traders | Active FX traders |
| Min Deposit | $0 | |
| Leverage | 1:200 for retail clients | |
| Spread | From 0.6 pips | From 0.0 pips |
| Commission | ❌ | 0.0025% |
| Stop Out Level (Retail & Pro) | 50% | |
| VPS | ✔ | |
| Hedging | ✔ | |
If an account remains inactive for 1 year—meaning no open positions or trading activity—it is considered dormant. For such accounts, a monthly inactivity fee of $15 AUD (or the equivalent in other currencies) will be charged. This fee is deducted from the account balance, usually within 3 business days of the start of the new month.

Additionally, CMC Markets provides free demo accounts wth $10,000 virtual funds, enabling traders to practice and familiarize themselves with the platform before opening a live account.
Demo MT4/5 accounts have initial period of 30 days, while no no expiry date for demo Next Generation account.
Traders have the flexibility to select the account type that aligns with their trading preferences, taking advantage of the benefits offered by each option.
How to Open a CMC Markets Account?
Step 1:Start the Process
Visit the CMC Markets website and click the “Open account” button located at the top right of the navigation bar.

Step 2: Choose Your Account Type
If you want to invest in shares, you can open a Share Investing account. If you want to trade CFDs, you can open a CMC account or MT4 account. Both offer demo accounts for practice. We recommend starting with a demo account to trade risk-free and familiarize yourself with the broker's trading conditions and platforms.

Step 3: Complete the Application
Follow the on-screen instructions to complete your application. You will need to fill in your personal information, including your email address, password, and more.

Step 4: Verify and Fund Your Account
Once your application is processed, verify your identity if required, and then you can fund your account to begin trading.
Leverage
The maximum leverage offered by CMC Markets is up to 1:200 for retail traders. While leverage can provide traders with several advantages, such as greater trading flexibility, potential for higher profits, increased market access, and enhanced trading opportunities, it also comes with certain disadvantages. One of the primary disadvantages is the increased risk exposure, as leverage magnifies both gains and losses. Traders need to exercise caution and implement proper risk management strategies to avoid significant losses. Additionally, the use of leverage requires a good understanding of the market and trading principles to make informed decisions.
Spreads and Commissions
CMC Markets offers competitive spreads for major currency pairs, with a live spread form indicating indicative prices. However, it's important to note that spreads may vary, especially during volatile market conditions. The company adopts a transparent commission structure, with commissions varying depending on the specific instruments traded.
| Account Type | Spread (FX) | Commission (FX) |
| Standard | From 0.6 pips | ❌ |
| FX Active | From 0.0 pips | 0.0025% |
Share CFD commissions vary on the country where the share product originates. It is worth mentioning that share commissions are subject to minimum charge requirements, such as the minimum commission charge of US$10 for US shares. Traders should carefully consider these factors and evaluate their trading strategies to effectively manage spreads, commissions, and other associated costs.
| Country/Market | Commission | Min Commission |
| UK | 0.08% | GBP 9.00 |
| US | 2 cents per unit | USD 10.00 |
| Australia | 0.09% | AUD 7.00 |
For detailed pricing, visit https://www.cmcmarkets.com/en-au/cfd/pricing


Trading Platform
CMC Markets provides traders with three platform options: MT4, MT5, and CMC NextGen.
MT4/5 is a widely recognized and popular trading platform known for its extensive range of technical indicators and automated trading tools. It offers a user-friendly interface and provides access to a diverse set of features.
On the other hand, CMC NextGen platform is a proprietary platform specifically designed for CMC Markets clients. It offers seamless integration with other CMC Markets services and features, providing a cohesive trading experience.
Traders can choose the platform that suits their preferences, whether they prefer the familiarity and customization options of MT4/5 or the integrated features of CMC Markets platform.
Deposit and Withdrawal
CMC Markets accepts deposits and withdrawals via credit/debit card, bank transfer, PayID or PayPal. The deposit fee is 1% for credit card payments and 0.6% for debit cards, while no any info on withdrawal fees.
Educational Resources
CMC Markets provides a comprehensive knowledge hub. Here, you can access market news and analysis, and learn about share investing with guides on getting started, platform use, investing basics, ETFs, and international markets. Additionally, you can explore CFD trading through their CFD knowledge hub, platform guides, MT4 academy, trading strategies, and trading guides.

CMC Markets also provides a user-friendly navigation system with various labels to help you quickly find what you need. These labels include Beginner, Advanced, Forex, How-to, Shares, Indices, Charting, Platform, Research, Strategy, Treasuries, Rates and Bonds, Commodities, Share Baskets, and Research Tools.

For instance, if you're a beginner looking for educational resources, simply click the “Beginner” label to view relevant materials. If you're interested in tutorials, the “How-to” label will guide you to those resources.
Explore more on their website for a well-designed and intuitive user experience.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
What are the trading platforms offered by CMC Markets?
CMC Markets provides MT4/5 and CMC NextGen.
Is there a minimum initial deposit required to open an account with CMC Markets?
No, CMC Markets does not require a minimum initial deposit.
Does CMC Markets offer a demo account?
Yes. Demo MT4/5 accounts have initial period of 30 days, while no no expiry date for demo Next Generation account.
excentral
| Aspect | Information |
| Company Name | eXcentral |
| Registered Country/Area | South Africa |
| Founded Year | 2018 |
| Regulation | Revoked |
| Minimum Deposit | $1,000 |
| Market Instruments | Forex,Commodities,Indices |
| Account Types | Classic,VIP,Gold |
| Leverage | Up to 1:30 |
| Spreads&commissions | Spreads:0.06-2.5pip,no commissions |
| Trading Platforms | MT4,MT5 platform |
| Demo Account | Available |
| Customer Support | Email:inquiriesaexcentral-int.com,Phone:+278 71 951005 |
| Deposit & Withdrawal | Bank transfer,debit/credit card,third party payment |
Overview of eXcentral
eXcentral, founded in 2018 and based in South Africa, is a financial services company that has had its regulation revoked. The firm requires a minimum deposit of $1,000 and offers trading in Forex, commodities, and indices.
eXcentral provides various account types including Classic, VIP, and Gold, catering to different levels of traders. The company offers leverage of up to 1:30 and boasts competitive trading conditions with spreads ranging from 0.06 to 0.1 pip, without charging commissions.
Traders have access to both MT4 and MT5 platforms, popular choices for their robust features and user-friendliness. A demo account is also available for practice trading. Customer support can be reached via email at inquiriesaexcentral-int.com or by phone at +278 71 951005.
For deposits and withdrawals, eXcentral accepts bank transfers, debit/credit cards, and third-party payments. However, the revocation of its regulation takes about its credibility and the safety of client funds.

Is eXcentral Limited Legit or a Scam?
eXcentral, operating under the licensed institution OM BRIDGE (PTY) LTD, had its regulatory status revoked by the Financial Sector Conduct Authority in South Africa.
The company, which held the license number 48296 since June 6, 2017, was categorized as a Financial Service Corporate. The revocation of its license raises significant concerns regarding its compliance with financial regulatory standards and the overall safety and legitimacy of its operations.
The licensed institution is located at UNIT 6C3, 159 Rivonia Road Sinosteel Plaza, Morningside Ext 39 Sandton, and can be contacted at the phone number 27072 216 2542. However, given the revocation of its regulatory status, caution is advised when considering any engagement with eXcentral.
The reason for the revocation and the current operational status of the company would require further investigation for anyone considering their services.

Pros and Cons
| Pros | Cons |
| Diverse Market Instruments | Regulation Revoked |
| Multiple Account Types | High Minimum Deposit |
| Competitive Spreads | Uncertain Operational Status |
| Access to MT4 and MT5 Platforms | Limited Information on Licensed Institution |
| Demo Account Availability | Potential Risk to Investors |
Pros:
Diverse Market Instruments: Offers trading in Forex, commodities, and indices, providing a range of options for traders.
Multiple Account Types: Availability of Classic, VIP, and Gold accounts caters to different levels of traders, offering flexibility and tailored trading experiences.
Competitive Spreads: Claims to offer low spreads ranging from 0.06 to 0.1 pip, which can be beneficial for cost-effective trading.
Access to MT4 and MT5 Platforms: Both platforms are well-regarded in the trading community for their advanced features and user-friendly interfaces.
Demo Account Availability: Provides a demo account, allowing new traders to practice and get acquainted with the platforms without financial risk.
Cons:
Regulation Revoked: The revocation of its regulatory status by the Financial Sector Conduct Authority in South Africa is a major red flag, indicating potential issues with compliance and reliability.
High Minimum Deposit: A minimum deposit of $1,000 might be relatively high for beginner traders or those looking to test the waters with smaller investments.
Uncertain Operational Status: The revocation of its license raises questions about the current operational status and the safety of client funds.
Limited Information on Licensed Institution: Lack of detailed information about the licensed institution OM BRIDGE (PTY) LTD, including its website and email address, hinders transparency.
Potential Risk to Investors: Given regulatory concerns, there is a heightened risk for anyone considering investing or trading with eXcentral.
Market Instruments
eXcentral offers trading in a range of market instruments, which include:
Forex: This includes a variety of currency pairs, allowing traders to speculate on the changing values of currencies against each other.
Commodities: These typically involve trading in natural resources such as gold, silver, oil, and agricultural products. Commodities trading can be a way to diversify a trading portfolio beyond forex and indices.
Indices: Trading in indices involves speculating on the price movements of index funds, which represent the aggregated performance of a selection of stocks. Indices usually reflect the performance of a particular sector or the broader market.

Account Types
Classic Trading Account:
The Classic Trading Account at eXcentral is designed for entry-level traders, offering leverage up to 1:30. It features a 2.5 spread on EUR/USD and a $0.10 spread on Crude Oil, catering to those who prefer trading in major forex pairs and commodities.
This account includes negative balance protection, which can be a safety net for traders against going into debt. Additionally, it comes with free trading education, providing resources for beginners to learn and develop their trading skills.
VIP Account:
eXcentral's VIP Account is tailored for more advanced traders, maintaining the same leverage of up to 1:30. It offers narrower spreads, with 0.9 on EUR/USD and $0.06 on Crude Oil, which can be appealing for more frequent or experienced traders.
This account enhances the trading experience with added features like educational webinars, SMS MTE trading signals for timely market insights, and weekly account overviews for a regular summary of trading performance.
The VIP Account is a step up for those seeking more in-depth market analysis and educational support.
Gold Account:
The Gold Account at eXcentral is geared towards serious, committed traders, providing leverage up to 1:30. It offers competitive spreads of 1.8 on EUR/USD and $0.08 on Crude Oil.
Alongside the benefits found in the VIP Account, the Gold Account introduces a monthly account overview for comprehensive performance tracking and the services of a dedicated senior account manager for personalized trading support.
Exclusive one-on-one sessions are a standout feature, offering bespoke guidance and strategy discussion, making this account suitable for those seeking a highly tailored trading experience.

| Account Type | Leverage | EUR/USD Spread | Crude Oil Spread |
| Classic | Up to 1:30 | 2.5 | $0.10 |
| VIP | Up to 1:30 | 0.9 | $0.06 |
| Gold | Up to 1:30 | 1.8 | $0.08 |
How to Open an Account?
Opening an account with eXcentral typically involves the following four steps:
Account Selection:
Begin by choosing the type of trading account that best suits your trading needs and experience level. eXcentral offers Classic, VIP, and Gold accounts, each with different features and spreads.
Registration Process:
Complete the registration form on eXcentrals website. This process usually requires providing personal information such as your name, address, contact details, and possibly some financial information to assess your trading experience and risk tolerance.
Verification (KYC Process):
As part of the Know Your Customer (KYC) process, submit the necessary documents for identity verification. This typically includes a government-issued ID (like a passport or drivers license), proof of residence (such as a utility bill or bank statement), and possibly additional financial documents.
Fund Your Account:
Once your account is verified, deposit funds to meet the minimum deposit requirement, which is $1,000 for eXcentral. Choose a suitable deposit method from the options available, such as bank transfer, debit/credit card, or third-party payment methods.
After completing these steps, youll be able to access the trading platform (MT4 or MT5) provided by eXcentral and start trading with the chosen account type.
Leverage
eXcentral offers leverage of up to 1:30 across its trading accounts, which includes the Classic, VIP, and Gold account types. This level of leverage allows traders to control a larger position with a relatively smaller amount of capital.
For example, with a leverage of 1:30, a trader can hold a position worth up to 30 times their account balance. While this can amplify potential profits, it also significantly increases the risk of losses, especially in volatile market conditions.
Therefore, it's important for traders to use leverage cautiously and understand its implications fully. Leverage is a powerful tool in trading, but it requires a good understanding of risk management to use effectively, particularly for less experienced traders.
Spreads & Commissions
eXcentral offers trading conditions with competitive spreads and no commission fees. The specifics of their spreads and commissions are as follows:
Spreads
eXcentral advertises spreads as low as 0.06 to 2.5 pip, which is quite tight and can be beneficial for traders looking to minimize their trading costs.
For example, the spread for EUR/USD ranges from 0.06 pip in the VIP account to 2.5 pips in the Classic account. Similarly, the spread for Crude Oil varies from $0.06 in the VIP account to $0.10 in the Classic account.
Such low spreads are particularly advantageous for high-frequency traders or those who trade large volumes.
Commissions:
The company states that it charges no commissions on trades. This means that traders don't have to pay a separate fee for each trade they execute, which is a cost-effective feature for active traders.
While these trading conditions appear attractive, especially for those looking to keep their trading costs low, it is crucial for traders to consider the overall context of the brokerage, including its regulatory status and reliability.

| Account Type | Spread from | Commission ($) |
| Raw | 0.2 | 7 |
| Real 1.0 | 1.5 | No |
| Real 2.0 | 2.5 | No |
Trading Platform
eXcentral offers its clients two well-regarded trading platforms: MetaTrader 4 (MT4) and MetaTrader 5 (MT5).
MT4 Platform: MT4 is one of the most popular trading platforms in the forex and CFD trading community. It is known for its user-friendly interface, robust technical analysis tools, a wide array of charting options, and support for automated trading through Expert Advisors (EAs).
MT5 Platform: As the successor to MT4, the MT5 platform offers extended features and capabilities. It supports more types of trading orders and has additional timeframes for analysis. MT5 also provides access to more indicators and analytical tools, along with enhanced charting capabilities.
Both platforms offer mobile versions, allowing traders to manage their accounts and trade from anywhere. The choice between MT4 and MT5 typically depends on the trader's preference, trading style, and the specific instruments they wish to trade.

Deposit & Withdrawal
eXcentral offers various options for deposit and withdrawal, including a specific minimum deposit requirement:
Minimum Deposit: The minimum amount required to open an account with eXcentral is $1,000. This sets a relatively high entry barrier, especially for novice traders or those who prefer to start with a smaller capital investment.
Payment Methods:
Bank Transfer: Allows for direct transfer of funds from a trader's bank account to their trading account. This method is typically secure but may take several days to process.
Debit/Credit Card: Offers a quick and convenient way to deposit funds using widely accepted cards like Visa and MasterCard.
Third-Party Payment: Accepts deposits via various third-party payment systems, which could include digital wallets or online payment services. These methods often provide quick and easy transactions.
Customer Support
eXcentral provides customer support through multiple channels, aiming to assist clients with their queries and issues. Customers can reach out via email at inquiriesaexcentral-int.com, offering a direct line of communication for support, queries, or feedback.
Additionally, they provide phone support at +278 71 951005, which can be beneficial for immediate assistance or for discussing more complex issues. The availability of these support options suggests a commitment to maintaining accessible customer service.

Conclusion
In summary, eXcentral, based in South Africa and founded in 2018, offers Forex, commodities, and indices trading on both the MT4 and MT5 platforms, with account options including Classic, VIP, and Gold. They provide leverage up to 1:30 and competitive spreads with no commission fees.
However, a significant concern is their revoked regulatory status, which poses serious questions about the firm's credibility and the safety of client investments.
While they offer a minimum deposit of $1,000 and multiple channels for customer support, potential clients should approach with caution and thoroughly evaluate the risks due to the regulatory concerns.
FAQs
Q:What trading platforms does eXcentral offer?
A:eXcentral provides the MetaTrader 4 (MT4) and MetaTrader 5 (MT5) platforms for trading.
Q:What is the minimum deposit required to open an account with eXcentral?
A:The minimum deposit required to open an account with eXcentral is $1,000.
Q:What types of trading accounts does eXcentral offer?
A:eXcentral offers three types of accounts: Classic, VIP, and Gold, each with different features and spreads.
Q:What leverage does eXcentral offer?
A:eXcentral offers leverage up to 1:30 across all its trading accounts.
Q:How can I deposit or withdraw funds from eXcentral?
A:Deposits and withdrawals can be made via bank transfer, debit/credit card, or third-party payment methods.
Q:How can I contact eXcentral's customer support?
A:Customer support can be reached via email at inquiriesaexcentral-int.com or by phone at +278 71 951005.
Do cmc-markets and excentral have lower transaction costs?
To compare transaction costs across different brokers, our experts analyze the transaction-specific fees (such as spreads) and non-trading fees (such as inactivity fees and payment costs).
To get a comprehensive understanding of how cheap or expensive cmc-markets and excentral are, we first considered common fees for standard accounts. On cmc-markets, the average spread for the EUR/USD currency pair is From 0.0 pips, while on excentral the spread is EUR/USD 2.5, GBP/USD 2.8, USD/JPY 2.8, Crude Oil $0.14.
Which broker between cmc-markets, excentral is safer?
To determine the safety of our top brokers, our experts will consider many factors. This includes which licenses the broker holds and the credibility of these licenses. We also consider the history of brokers, because long-term brokers are usually more reliable and trustworthy than new brokers.
cmc-markets is regulated by ASIC,FCA,FCA,ASIC,FMA,CIRO,MAS. excentral is regulated by FSCA.
Which broker between cmc-markets, excentral provides better trading platform?
When our experts review brokers, they will open their own accounts and trade through the broker's trading platform. This enables them to comprehensively evaluate the quality, ease of use, and function of the platform.
cmc-markets provides the CMC Markets Platform ,MT4/MT5 platform with products like Forex, Indices, Shares, Commodities, ETFs, Treasuries, Share baskets, Cryptocurrencies; excentral offers the Classic,Silver,Gold,VIP platform featuring assets including --.













