Global Broker Regulation Inquiry App
About WikiFX
English
简体中文
繁體中文
English
Pусский
日本語
ภาษาไทย
Tiếng Việt
Bahasa Indonesia
Español
हिन्दी
Filippiiniläinen
Français
Deutsch
Português
Türkçe
한국어
العربية
اردو
Yuanta , FXCL Broker Comparison
Do you want to know which is the better broker between Yuanta and FXCL ?
In the table below, you can compare the features of Yuanta , FXCL side by side to determine the best fit for your needs.
- Rating
- Basic Information
- Trading Env.
- Account Info
- Related News
- Relevant Exposures
- Rating
- Basic Information
- Trading Env.
- Account Info
- Related News
- Relevant Exposures
2 forex brokers comparison in total
Rating
Score
Regulatory Status
WikiFX Guarantee
WikiFX Survey
Risk Evaluation
Exposure
Official Website
Basic Information
Est. Date (years)
Regulatory License
MT4
MT5
Crypto
Deposit/Withdrawal Methods
Trading Env.
Trading Environment Rating
Execution Speed
Trading Speed Rating
Average Execution Speed (ms)
Minimum Execution Latency (ms)
Minimum Open Latency (ms)
Minimum Close Latency (ms)
Maximum Execution Latency (ms)
Maximum Open Latency (ms)
Maximum Close Latency (ms)
Slippage
Slippage Rating
Average Slippage
Max Slippage
Maximum Positive Slippage
Maximum Negative Slippage
Trading Cost
Trading Cost Rating
- Average Trading Cost (USD/Lot)
Swap
Swap Rating
- Average Swap Cost (USD/Lot)
Disconnection Instances
Disconnection Rating
Avg. Disconnection Frequency (/day)
Avg. Reconnection Time (ms)
Account Info
Accounts
Account Name
Trading Instruments
Minimum Deposit
Maximum Leverage
Typical Spread
Stop-Out Level
Spread Types
Minimum Trade Size
Crypto
Lock Position
Scalping
EA Trading
Pin to Left
7.04
Regulated
Not Guaranteed
--
20+ years
SFC,SFC
Not Supported
Not Supported
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
Pin to Left
2.25
Not Regulated
Not Guaranteed
--
5-10 years
VFSC
Supported
Not Supported
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
ECN Pro,Volume Cash,Live Contest,Interbank Standard,Interbank Cent,Start ,Standard,Cent
--
--
Forex,metals 1:300, Indices 1:100, Crypto 1:10
from 0.1
80.00
Floating
0.01
--
Score
Regulatory Status
Regulated
Not Regulated
FXCL BrokerRelated News
Yuanta 、 FXCL BrokerRelevant Exposures
Which broker is more reliable?
To evaluate a broker's reliability and trustworthiness, consider the following four factors:
1.Forex broker introduction。
2.Do yuanta and fxcl have lower transaction costs?
3.Which broker is safer?
4.Which broker offers the best trading platform?
Based on these four factors, we can compare which is reliable. We have broken down the reasons as follows:
Forex broker introduction
yuanta
| Yuanta Review Summary | |
| Founded | 1992 |
| Registered Country/Region | Hong Kong |
| Regulation | SFC |
| Market Instruments | Stocks, derivatives, futures & options |
| Demo Account | ❌ |
| Trading Platform | eWinner, YSHK SP Trader |
| Minimum Deposit | / |
| Customer Support | Phone: (852) 3555-7878 |
| Fax: (852) 3555-7889 | |
| Email: HK.services.brk@yuanta.com | |
Yuanta Information
Founded in 1992, Yuanta is governed by the Hong Kong Securities and Futures Commission. The company provides a variety of trading tools including stocks, futures, and derivatives. Though it lacks a demo account, it helps multi-platform trading with in-house created technologies and provides localised support via phone and email.
Pros and Cons
| Pros | Cons |
| Regulated by Hong Kong SFC | No demo accounts |
| Supports multi-market trading through one login | Some service fees (e.g., nominee services) can be high |
| Offers broad product coverage: stocks, futures, options | No clearly stated minimum deposit |
Is Yuanta Legit?
Yes, Yuanta is regulated by Securities and Futures Commission of Hong Kong (SFC).
| Licensed Entity | Regulated by | Regulated License | Current Status | License Type | License No. |
| Yuanta Securities (Hong Kong) Company Limited | Hong Kong, China | SFC | Regulated | Dealing in futures contracts | ABS015 |
| Yuanta Futures (HK) Co., Limited | Hong Kong, China | SFC | Regulated | Dealing in futures contracts | AXQ690 |
| Yuanta Asia Investment (Hong Kong) Limited | Hong Kong, China | SFC | Exceeded | Dealing in securities | ABZ023 |
What Can I Trade on Yuanta?
Mainly covering stock trading, derivative products, and futures & options, the organization provides a broad spectrum of financial products and services.
| Trading Products | Details |
| Stock Trading | HK Stocks, SH Stocks, SZ Stocks, Taiwan Stocks, US Stocks, China B Shares, Overseas Stocks |
| Derivative Products | Callable Bull / Bear Contracts, Derivative Warrants |
| Futures & Options | Futures, Options, Trading Details, Contract Specifications, Margin Requirements |
Yuanta Fees
Though some administrative and nominee service fees could be on the higher side, Yuanta's fees are usually in line with industry standards, with standard commission and interest rates similar to major Hong Kong brokers.
| Item | Charge |
| Standard Commission Rate | 0.25% of transaction amount, Minimum HK$100 |
| Standard Margin Interest Rate | Prime Rate + 5% |
| Stamp Duty | 0.10% (after 17 Nov 2023), 0.13% (before), min HK$1 |
| Transaction Levy | 0.0027% of transaction amount |
| Trading Fee | 0.00565% of transaction amount (since Jan 2023) |
| CCASS Fee | 0.002%, min HK$2, max HK$100 |
| Italian Financial Transaction Tax | 0.2% of transaction amount |
| FRC Transaction Levy | 0.00015% of transaction amount |
Trading Platform
Yuanta offers a suite of trading platforms under the eWinner and YSHK SP Trader brands, designed for both desktop and mobile users.
| Trading Platform | Supported | Available Devices |
| eWinner | ✔ | Web, PC, iOS, Android |
| YSHK SP Trader | ✔ | PC, iOS, Android |
Deposit and Withdrawal
Yuanta does not charge deposit or withdrawal fees directly, but third-party banks may impose charges depending on the method (especially for CHATS/RTGS and overseas remittance). No specific minimum deposit amount is mentioned in the policy.
| Payment Method | Fees (Yuanta) | Processing Time | Notes |
| Cheque Deposit | 0 | Next business day | Cheque copy & receipt with account info required |
| Local Bank Transfer | 0 (via SCBHK), others may charge | Same business day | SCBHK transfers free; non-SCBHK/CHATS may incur fees |
| CHATS/RTGS | Waived under HKD/RMB 1 million (temp.) | Larger amounts may incur third-party charges | |
| Overseas Remittance | Yuanta: 0; Bank charges apply | 1–2 business days (depends on correspondent bank) | Full bank and SWIFT details required per currency |
| Mobile App (2FA) | 0 | Same day (if before cutoff) | Withdrawal via mobile app requires authentication |
| Email Instruction | 0 | Processed on same or next business day | Must email with account name & number before cutoff (5:00pm HKT) |
fxcl
| FXCLReview Summary | |
| Founded | 2006 |
| Registered Country/Region | Saint Vincent and the Grenadines |
| Regulation | VFSC |
| Market Instruments | Forex, indices, cryptocurrencies, metals |
| Demo Account | ✔ |
| Leverage | Up to 1:2000 |
| Spread | Low |
| Trading Platform | MT4 Margin WebTrader |
| Min Deposit | $1 |
| Customer Support | Email: support@fxclearing.com |
| Registered office: Plot 54368 Western Commercial Road, The Hub, Itowers, Cbd, Gaborone, Botswana. | |
FXCL Information
FXCL, founded in 2006, is a forex brokerage registered in Saint Vincent and the Grenadines. It is regulated by VFSC. Its current status is revoked. It charges no fees or commissions. Its leverage is up to 1:2000.
Pros and Cons
| Pros | Cons |
| VFSC regulated | Limited customer support options |
| Wide range of currency pairs and trading instruments | Fixed spreads |
| Low minimum deposit of $1 | No Islamic trading account |
| Eight types of trading accounts to choose from | No MT5 supported |
| Generous leverage up to 1:2000 | No phone number information offered |
| Competitive spreads and low trading fees | |
| MT4 trading platform and webtrader supported | |
| Copy trading available | |
| Demo account available |
Is FXCL Legit?
FXCL is regulated by VFSC in Vanuatu. Its current status is revoked.
| Regulated Country | Regulated Authority | Regulated Entity | License Type | License Number | Current Status |
| Vanuatu | VFSC | FXCL Markets Ltd | Retail Forex License | 14610 | Revoked |
What Can I Trade On FXCL?
FXCL offers traders forex, indices, cryptocurrencies, metals to trade.
| Tradable Instruments | Supported |
| Forex | ✔ |
| Indices | ✔ |
| Metals | ✔ |
| Cryptocurrencies | ✔ |
| Commodities | ❌ |
| Stocks | ❌ |
| Futures | ❌ |
| Options | ❌ |
Account Types
FXCL offers 4 different types of accounts to traders - Start Account, Cent Account, Standard Account, Interbank Cent Account, Interbank Standard Account, ECN Pro Account, Live Contest Account, Volume Cash Account. It also provides demo accounts.
| Account Type | Start Account | Cent Account | Standard Account | Interbank Cent Account | Interbank Standard Account | ECN Pro Account | Live Contest Account | Volume Cash Account |
| Leverage | 1:2000 | 1:1000 | 1:500 | 1:500 | 1:500 | 1:300 | 1:1000 | 1:1000 |
| Spreads | Floating for full spread list | Fixed for fufor full spread list | Fixed for fufor full spread list | Floating starting from 1.1 pip with a 5-digit price feed for full spread list | Floating,starting from 1.1 pip with a 5-digit price feed for full spread list | Floating, starting from 0.1 pip with a 5-digit price feed | Floating for full spread list | Floating for full spread list |
| Position Size | 0.01-1.00 (standard lot) | 0.01-200 (micro lot) | 0.01-2.00 (standard lot) | 0.01-500 (micro lot) | 0.01-5.00 (standard lot) | 0.01-50.00 (standard lot) | 0.01-3.00 (standard lot) | 0.01-3.00 (standard lot) |
| Execution | Market | Instant | Instant/Market | Market | Market | Market | Automatic Market Execution | Automatic Market Execution |
FXCL Fees
FXCL's spreads are as low as 0 pips. FXCL charges low commissions. It charges $3 per lot for forex, metals, indices 0.15% per lot of Crypto when transaction happens in ECN Account and $1.5 per lot for forex, metals when transaction happens in Live Contest Account and Volume Cash Account. The min deposit is $1.
Trading Platform
FXCL's trading platform is MT4 Margin WebTrader, which supports traders on PC, Mac, iPhone and Android.
| Trading Platform | Supported | Available Devices | Suitable for |
| MT4 Margin WebTrader | ✔ | Web, Mobile | Beginner |
| MT5 | ❌ |
Deposit and Withdrawal
FXCL offers a lot of deposit and withdrawal methods.
Deposit
| Method | Processing Time | Fees |
| Online bank (Asiabank) | Instant | N/A |
| Crypto (Alphacoins) | Instant | N/A |
| PerfectMoney | Instant | Low fees |
| Local Deposit | Up to 1 business day | Low fees |
| FasaPay | Quick | FXCL provides full fee coverage for all Fasapay deposits |
| Dragonpay | Instant | N/A |
Withdrawal
| Method | Processing Time | Fees |
| Online bank (Asiabank) | Instant | N/A |
| Crypto (Alphacoins) | Instant | N/A |
| PerfectMoney | Instant | Low fees |
| Local Deposit | Up to 1 business day | Low fees |
| FasaPay | Quick | Low fees |
| Dragonpay | Instant | N/A |
Copy Trading
FXCL's copytrading offers an opportunity to automatically follow good traders and monitor the markets.
Any FXCL client may open an ECN Copy Pro account as a Follower (hereinafter, Follower‘s Account).In order to open an ECN Copy Pro account as a Signal Provider (hereinafter, Provider’s Account), the client should verify the Traders Cabinet first and provide a link to his/her previous trading results on Myfxbook, MQL5 or FX Blue resource or upload an MT4 statement from his/her previous trading account (any account type from any broker is allowed).
Do yuanta and fxcl have lower transaction costs?
To compare transaction costs across different brokers, our experts analyze the transaction-specific fees (such as spreads) and non-trading fees (such as inactivity fees and payment costs).
To get a comprehensive understanding of how cheap or expensive yuanta and fxcl are, we first considered common fees for standard accounts. On yuanta, the average spread for the EUR/USD currency pair is -- pips, while on fxcl the spread is from 0.1.
Which broker between yuanta, fxcl is safer?
To determine the safety of our top brokers, our experts will consider many factors. This includes which licenses the broker holds and the credibility of these licenses. We also consider the history of brokers, because long-term brokers are usually more reliable and trustworthy than new brokers.
yuanta is regulated by SFC,SFC. fxcl is regulated by VFSC.
Which broker between yuanta, fxcl provides better trading platform?
When our experts review brokers, they will open their own accounts and trade through the broker's trading platform. This enables them to comprehensively evaluate the quality, ease of use, and function of the platform.
yuanta provides the -- platform with products like --; fxcl offers the ECN Pro,Volume Cash,Live Contest,Interbank Standard,Interbank Cent,Start ,Standard,Cent platform featuring assets including --.
