Global Broker Regulation Inquiry App
About WikiFX
Broker Search
English

简体中文

繁體中文

English

Pусский

日本語

ภาษาไทย

Tiếng Việt

Bahasa Indonesia

Español

हिन्दी

Filippiiniläinen

Français

Deutsch

Português

Türkçe

한국어

العربية

اردو

Download

Yuanta , A3TRADING Broker Comparison

Do you want to know which is the better broker between Yuanta and A3TRADING ?

In the table below, you can compare the features of Yuanta , A3TRADING side by side to determine the best fit for your needs.

  • Rating
  • Basic Information
  • Trading Env.
  • Account Info
  • Relevant Exposures
  • Rating
  • Basic Information
  • Trading Env.
  • Account Info
  • Relevant Exposures
 2 / 3  forex brokers comparison in total
Rating
Score
Regulatory Status
WikiFX Guarantee
WikiFX Survey
Risk Evaluation
Exposure
Basic Information
Est. Date
Regulatory License
MT4
MT5
Crypto
Deposit/Withdrawal Methods
Trading Env.
Trading Environment Rating
Execution Speed
Trading Speed Rating
Average Execution Speed
Minimum Execution Latency
Minimum Open Latency
Minimum Close Latency
Maximum Execution Latency
Maximum Open Latency
Maximum Close Latency
Slippage
Slippage Rating
Average Slippage
Max Slippage
Maximum Positive Slippage
Maximum Negative Slippage
Trading Cost
Trading Cost Rating
  • Average Trading Cost
  • (EURUSD)
  • Average Trading Cost
  • (XAUUSD)
Swap
Swap Rating
  • Average Trading Cost
  • (EURUSD)
  • Average Trading Cost
  • (XAUUSD)
Disconnection Instances
Disconnection Rating
Avg. Disconnection Frequency (/day)
Avg. Reconnection Time
Account Info
Accounts
Account Name
Trading Instruments
Minimum Deposit
Maximum Leverage
Typical Spread
Stop-Out Level
Spread Types
Minimum Trade Size
Crypto
Lock Position
Scalping
EA Trading
Yuanta
7.04
Regulated
Under guarantee
--
20+ years
SFC,SFC
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
A3TRADING
1.64
Not Regulated
Under guarantee
--
5-10 years
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--

Yuanta 、 A3TRADING BrokerRelevant Exposures

Which broker is more reliable?

To evaluate a broker's reliability and trustworthiness, consider the following four factors:

1.Forex broker introduction。

2.Do yuanta and a3trading have lower transaction costs?

3.Which broker is safer?

4.Which broker offers the best trading platform?

Based on these four factors, we can compare which is reliable. We have broken down the reasons as follows:

Forex broker introduction

yuanta
Yuanta Review Summary
Founded1992
Registered Country/RegionHong Kong
RegulationSFC
Market InstrumentsStocks, derivatives, futures & options
Demo Account
Trading PlatformeWinner, YSHK SP Trader
Minimum Deposit/
Customer SupportPhone: (852) 3555-7878
Fax: (852) 3555-7889
Email: HK.services.brk@yuanta.com

Yuanta Information

Founded in 1992, Yuanta is governed by the Hong Kong Securities and Futures Commission. The company provides a variety of trading tools including stocks, futures, and derivatives. Though it lacks a demo account, it helps multi-platform trading with in-house created technologies and provides localised support via phone and email.

Yuanta Information

Pros and Cons

ProsCons
Regulated by Hong Kong SFCNo demo accounts
Supports multi-market trading through one loginSome service fees (e.g., nominee services) can be high
Offers broad product coverage: stocks, futures, optionsNo clearly stated minimum deposit

Is Yuanta Legit?

Yes, Yuanta is regulated by Securities and Futures Commission of Hong Kong (SFC).

Licensed EntityRegulated byRegulated LicenseCurrent StatusLicense TypeLicense No.
Yuanta Securities (Hong Kong) Company LimitedHong Kong, ChinaSFCRegulatedDealing in futures contractsABS015
Yuanta Futures (HK) Co., LimitedHong Kong, ChinaSFCRegulatedDealing in futures contractsAXQ690
Yuanta Asia Investment (Hong Kong) LimitedHong Kong, ChinaSFCExceededDealing in securitiesABZ023

license
license
license

What Can I Trade on Yuanta?

Mainly covering stock trading, derivative products, and futures & options, the organization provides a broad spectrum of financial products and services.

Trading ProductsDetails
Stock TradingHK Stocks, SH Stocks, SZ Stocks, Taiwan Stocks, US Stocks, China B Shares, Overseas Stocks
Derivative ProductsCallable Bull / Bear Contracts, Derivative Warrants
Futures & OptionsFutures, Options, Trading Details, Contract Specifications, Margin Requirements
Products and Services

Yuanta Fees

Though some administrative and nominee service fees could be on the higher side, Yuanta's fees are usually in line with industry standards, with standard commission and interest rates similar to major Hong Kong brokers.

ItemCharge
Standard Commission Rate0.25% of transaction amount, Minimum HK$100
Standard Margin Interest RatePrime Rate + 5%
Stamp Duty0.10% (after 17 Nov 2023), 0.13% (before), min HK$1
Transaction Levy0.0027% of transaction amount
Trading Fee0.00565% of transaction amount (since Jan 2023)
CCASS Fee0.002%, min HK$2, max HK$100
Italian Financial Transaction Tax0.2% of transaction amount
FRC Transaction Levy0.00015% of transaction amount
Yuanta Fees

Trading Platform

Yuanta offers a suite of trading platforms under the eWinner and YSHK SP Trader brands, designed for both desktop and mobile users.

Trading PlatformSupportedAvailable Devices
eWinnerWeb, PC, iOS, Android
YSHK SP Trader PC, iOS, Android
Trading Platform

Deposit and Withdrawal

Yuanta does not charge deposit or withdrawal fees directly, but third-party banks may impose charges depending on the method (especially for CHATS/RTGS and overseas remittance). No specific minimum deposit amount is mentioned in the policy.

Payment MethodFees (Yuanta)Processing TimeNotes
Cheque Deposit0Next business dayCheque copy & receipt with account info required
Local Bank Transfer0 (via SCBHK), others may chargeSame business daySCBHK transfers free; non-SCBHK/CHATS may incur fees
CHATS/RTGSWaived under HKD/RMB 1 million (temp.)Larger amounts may incur third-party charges
Overseas RemittanceYuanta: 0; Bank charges apply1–2 business days (depends on correspondent bank)Full bank and SWIFT details required per currency
Mobile App (2FA)0Same day (if before cutoff)Withdrawal via mobile app requires authentication
Email Instruction0Processed on same or next business dayMust email with account name & number before cutoff (5:00pm HKT)
Deposit and Withdrawal
a3trading
Registered in Cyprus
Regulated by No effective regulation at this time
Year(s) of establishment 2-5 years
Trading instruments Currency pairs, indices, commodities, metals, energy, cryptocurrencies, stocks
Minimum Initial Deposit $200
Maximum Leverage 1:200
Minimum spread Information not available
Trading platform own platform
Deposit and withdrawal method VISA, MasterCard, maestro, jiomoney, skrill, bank transfer, neteller, exopayz, paysafecard, paytm, mobikwik, globe pay, fast bank transfer, scardu, etcetera.
Customer Service Email, phone number, address, live chat
Fraud Complaints Exposure Yes

Risk Warning

Online trading involves huge risks and you can lose all your invested capital. It is not suitable for all traders or investors. Please ensure that you understand the risks involved and note that the information contained herein is for general information purposes only.

General information and regulations of A3Trading

A3Trading is an online forex broker registered in Cyprus and currently under no effective regulation.

In the following article, we will analyze the characteristics of this broker from various aspects, providing you with simple and organized information. If you are interested, please read on.

At the end of the article, we will also briefly summarize the main advantages and disadvantages so that you can understand the broker's characteristics at a glance.

Market instruments

Currency pairs, indices, commodities, metals, energy, cryptocurrencies, stocks.....A3Trading allows clients to access a huge range of trading markets. Therefore, both beginners and experienced traders can find what they want to trade on A3Trading.

market instruments

Spreads and commissions for trading with A3Trading

A3Trading does not detail on its website additional trading costs such as spreads, commissions, SWAPs, etc. These costs are very important when calculating profits and losses, and should be considered in aggregate and not chosen in isolation. If you want to trade with A3Trading, we recommend that you take the time to calculate these transaction costs.

Account Types for A3Trading

The minimum initial deposit to open an account at A3Trading is 200 USD. According to the information on its website, there is no demo account or multiple account types. However, there is a no-loss guarantee in the first 5 transactions, and A3Trading claims that the clients can take the profits and A3Trading will cover the possible losses.

In case of absence of any activity for a period of at least three (3) months, the Company reserves the right to apply a fee of US$ 500 thereafter, charged on a quarterly basis. If the Client account is funded by less than US$ 500 and has been inactive for a period of three (3) months, the Company reserves the right to charge a lower amount to cover administrative expenses and close down the account.

Trading platforms offered by A3Trading

The company's trading platform is an in-house developed platform that can be used on computers, tablets and cell phones.

trading platform

Leverage offered by A3Trading

Although some brokers offer leverage up to 1:500 or even 1:1000, the leverage of 1:200 offered by A3Trading is sufficient for the average trader. This is because the more leverage you have, the more risk you take with your money. Even professional traders, let alone novices, should not be tempted to use leverage as large as 1:500.

leverage

Deposit and withdrawal methods and fees

In order to withdraw from your account in A3Trading, you will need to provide a series of documents. The extra fees, minimum amount and processing time are not revealed. The feasible payment methods are: VISA, MasterCard, maestro, jiomoney, skrill, bank transfer, neteller, exopayz, paysafecard, paytm, mobikwik, globe pay, fast bank transfer, scardu, etcetera.

deposit and withdrawal

Educational resources

A series of educational resources is available at A3Trading, such as video lessons, autochartist, daily market review, economic calendar, live rates & charts, real-time trends, etcetera.

educational resources

Customer support of A3Trading

Below are the details about the customer service.

Language(s): English, Arabic, Spanish

Email: customer.service.en@a3trading.com

Phone Number: +441519471242

WhatsApp: +447441427300

Address: Wanakena Ltd, 73 Arch. Makarios III Avenue, Office 301, 1070 Nicosia, Cyprus.

customer support

Users exposures on WikiFX

On our website, you can see that some users have reported scams. Please be aware and exercise caution when investing. You can check our platform for information before trading. If you find such fraudulent brokers or have been a victim of one, please let us know in the Exposure section, we would appreciate it and our team of experts will do everything possible to solve the problem for you.

users' exposure

Advantages and disadvantages of A3Trading

Advantages:

Sufficient information

Educational resources

Many instruments available

Many deposit and withdrawal methods

Disadvantages:

Complaints

No effective regulation

Few information available

No MT4/MT5

No copy trading

Frequent asked questions about A3Trading

Is this broker well regulated?

No, it is currently not effectively regulated and you are advised to be aware of its potential risks.

How much leverage does this broker offer?

The maximum leverage of A3Trading is 1:200. Please note that this leverage may only be available for some accounts and products. Please consult our articles or the dealer's website for specific information.

Do yuanta and a3trading have lower transaction costs?

To compare transaction costs across different brokers, our experts analyze the transaction-specific fees (such as spreads) and non-trading fees (such as inactivity fees and payment costs).

To get a comprehensive understanding of how cheap or expensive yuanta and a3trading are, we first considered common fees for standard accounts. On yuanta, the average spread for the EUR/USD currency pair is -- pips, while on a3trading the spread is --.

Which broker between yuanta, a3trading is safer?

To determine the safety of our top brokers, our experts will consider many factors. This includes which licenses the broker holds and the credibility of these licenses. We also consider the history of brokers, because long-term brokers are usually more reliable and trustworthy than new brokers.

yuanta is regulated by SFC,SFC. a3trading is regulated by --.

Which broker between yuanta, a3trading provides better trading platform?

When our experts review brokers, they will open their own accounts and trade through the broker's trading platform. This enables them to comprehensively evaluate the quality, ease of use, and function of the platform.

yuanta provides the -- platform with products like --; a3trading offers the -- platform featuring assets including --.

Select Country/Region
United States
※ WikiFX compiles data from publicly available sources and user contributions. While we endeavor to maintain its accuracy, we do not warrant the information's completeness, accuracy, or timeliness, as it may become outdated. Investors are strongly advised to verify critical details with official sources before making any decisions.
You are visiting the WikiFX website. WikiFX Internet and its mobile products are an enterprise information searching tool for global users. When using WikiFX products, users should consciously abide by the relevant laws and regulations of the country and region where they are located.
consumer hotline:006531290538
Official Email:support@wikifx.com;
Mobile Phone Number:234 706 777 7762;61 449895363
Telegram:+60 103342306
Whatsapp:+852-6613 1970;
License or other information error corrections, please send the information to:qa@wikifx.com
Cooperation:business@wikifx.com